Lutz › Sunlake Park

19201 Alice Cir

Lutz, FL 33558
$515,000
4 bed2 bath1,936 sqftSingle-family home · built 1963

Listed at $266 per sq ft. Median for single-family homes with 4 bedrooms in Lutz sold in the last 12 months: $237 per sq ft.

191 sales · Stellar MLS, credited below

What stands out about this home

Compared with single-family homes like it, within product classi
Size
Larger than 31% of single-family homes sold in Lutz
1,232 single-family home sales · Jan 2024 - Oct 2026
Price
Listed 9% above the typical price for a single-family home its size in Lutz
1,232 single-family home sales · Jan 2024 - Oct 2026
Standout feature
Waterfront: 13% of single-family homes listed in Lutz are
596 single-family home listings · Jan 2005 - Oct 2026
Age
Newer than 1% of single-family homes in Lutz
1,916 homes · Jan 2005 - Oct 2026
Compared against 40 similar homes sold within 2.76 mi.

About this property

LOCATION, LAKEFRONT LIVING & THE LUTZ LIFESTYLE COME TOGETHER AT 19201 ALICE CIRCLE! Located in an exceptional Lutz location currently assigned to McKitrick Elementary, Martinez Middle and Steinbrenner High School, this distinctive 4-bedroom, 2-bath, 1,936 sq. ft. residence offers an opportunity to own a waterfront pool home overlooking beautiful Lake Alice in one of Lutz's established residential settings. Buyer to verify current school boundaries and eligibility.

Featuring a NEWER ROOF, new AC , NO HOA, NO CDD and FLOOD ZONE X, this bright and airy home sits on nearly ¼ acre and offers a combination of location, water views, outdoor living and flexibility that is increasingly difficult to find.

Step outside to a beautifully fenced backyard created for Florida living. Enjoy a sparkling spa like feel with the newer resurfaced PebbleTec-style pool overlooking Lake Alice, an expansive oversized pool deck, a fun tiki-style bar, mature tropical greenery and plenty of room for outdoor dining and entertaining. There's even space to create a Jacuzzi area or beautiful poolside garden.

Inside, natural light creates a bright and welcoming atmosphere. One of the home's most unique features is the oversized lower-level, basement-style room, providing incredible flexibility as a fourth bedroom, family gathering room, media room, den, home office or private retreat. An oversized carport tucked privately toward the rear of the property provides additional functionality while preserving the home's inviting setting.

LOCATION IS EVERYTHING. Enjoy the peaceful, established atmosphere of Lutz while remaining conveniently connected to Tampa Bay. With easy access to Lutz Lake Fern Road, Dale Mabry Highway and the Veterans/Suncoast Expressway, Downtown Tampa, Tampa International Airport, Busch Gardens, major employment centers, hospitals, shopping and restaurants are all within convenient driving distance. Florida's beautiful Gulf beaches are approximately 40–45 minutes away, depending on destination and traffic.

This is the balance so many buyers are searching for—peaceful waterfront and suburban living with mature surroundings and room to breathe, while still enjoying the conveniences of modern Tampa Bay living.

Whether you're searching for a primary residence, second home or investment opportunity, 19201 Alice Circle brings together an exceptional collection of features.

Lakefront living, a private pool and an exceptional Lutz setting—19201 Alice Circle is ready to be experienced. Schedule your private showing today and come take a look at this special property.

Property details

Year built1963
Lot size0.23 ac
HOANot stated
Parking2-car
Days on market22
MLS#TB8547899
Private yardCeiling fansBuilt-in ovenDishwasherRefrigeratorTile flooring
All features →
  • Private yard
  • Ceiling fans
  • Built-in oven
  • Dishwasher
  • Refrigerator
  • Tile flooring
  • Travertine flooring
  • Wood flooring
  • Water view
  • Central air conditioning
  • Central heating
  • Shingle roof
  • Block foundation
  • Block construction
  • Two stories
  • Inside laundry
  • Cable available
  • Electricity connected
  • Sewer connected
  • Water connected
  • Private pool
  • Garage
  • Carport
  • Waterfront

The market for homes like this

Single-family homes with 4 bedrooms in Lutz
i
Median sold price$585,000191 sales · last 12 months
Median price per sq ft$237191 sales · last 12 months
Median rent$3,172/mo56 leases · last 12 months
Median days to lease2856 leases · last 12 months

Lutz, as its listings describe it

What agents stated on listings, 2005 – 2026i
Community pool53%of 554 listings
HOA fee, median$133/moof 527 listings
Has an association82%of 847 listings
Pets allowed91%of 1,138 listings
Minimum lease, most commonNo Minimum39% of 613 listings · next: 1–2 Years
Lease restrictions56%of 616 listings
Association approval required33%of 553 listings
Private pool21%of 1,215 listings
Gated47%of 554 listings
Public water · sewer86% · 86%of 696 · 735 listings
Flood zone (A or V)5%of 736 listings
55+ communityNo100% of 853 listings · next: Yes
Homestead share Sunlake Park76%of 136 homes · county tax roll
Also stated: waterfront 11% of 854 listings; CDD 20% of 650.

Price and time on market

This listing against homes like iti
Price per sq ft
Listed at $266 per sq ft, 12% above the $237 median for 4-bedroom single-family homes in Lutz sold in the last 12 months
191 sales · last 12 months
Time on market
On the market 22 days; 4-bedroom single-family homes in Lutz took a median of 24 days to sell in the last 12 months
191 sales · last 12 months
Price history
Listed at $559,000 originally; now $515,000, 7.9% lower after at least two price reductions. The most recent: down $5,000 on Oct. 10, 2026
at least two price reductions visible

Cost of ownership

What this home costs to hold, from public recordsi
Current owner's taxes
i
$4,450 for 2025 on the listing; about $3,696 on the 2026 roll
The listing and the county roll disagree materially; both are shown
Estimated taxes at this price
i
About $6,500/yr homesteaded, $7,300/yr as an investor
Estimated: the asking price through the county's price-to-value factor, at the parcel's published millage; assessments reset at sale
Typical electric bill
i
$170/mo (2024)
Typical: the utility's average residential bill for 2024 (not this home's)
Typical water and sewer
i
$98/mo at 5,000 gallons
Typical: the provider's published schedule at 5,000 gallons a month on a standard residential meter
THE NEIGHBORHOOD

Living in Lutz

unincorporated Hillsborough County · Hillsborough County · ZIP 33558 · Cheval (census-designated place) · Flood zone X*
Explore Lutz →
Homes13,140residential parcels
Median sold price$476,000555 sales · last 12 months
Vs. the prior year-6.1%555 sales this year · 553 sales the prior year
Median rent$2,500/mo237 leases · last 12 months
Homes that changed hands4%555 sales of 13,140 homes
Homestead share76%of 13,140 homes · county tax roll
Single-family homes in Lutz, by bedroomsFigures appear once a group has 40 sales
GROUPSALESMEDIAN SOLDMEDIAN RENT
All single-family homes · 12 months431$545,000$2,750/mo149 leases
2 bed9Not enough sales yet to report on their own
3 bed143$393,300$2,360/mo69 leases
4 bed · this home191$585,000$3,172/mo56 leases
5+ bed88$785,250—
All single-family homes · 24 months869$559,000$2,700/mo296 leases
Median price

Lutz homes sold for a median of $476,000 in the 12 months to Oct. 11, 2026.

555 sales
Price trend

That's 6.1% below the median for the 12 months before, $507,000.

555 sales this year · 553 sales the prior year
What's selling

Single-family detached homes made up 431 of the 555 sales in the same 12 months, at a median of $545,000.

431 of 555 sales
Not yet available here: rent and time-to-lease for condos.The Lutz record: homes, prices, rents, communities and listings →

Location

19201 ALICE CIR, LUTZ, FL 33558

Nearby homes for sale in Lutz

Based on information from Stellar MLS® for the period January 12, 2005 through October 11, 2026.

Listings courtesy of Stellar MLS as distributed by MLS GRID

HomeProp is a licensed Florida real estate brokerage (License CQ1055163). Regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC), 400 W Robinson St, Orlando, FL 32801. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

← Browse homes for sale
Request a showing