Winter Haven › Hutchinson

716 Avenue I Ne

Winter Haven, FL 33881
$258,500
3 bed1.5 bath1,559 sqftSingle-family home · built 1951

What stands out about this home

Compared with single-family homes like it, within product classi
Size
Larger than 27% of single-family homes sold in Winter Haven
2,750 single-family home sales · Jan 2024 - Sep 2026
Price
The seller has not permitted automated price comparisons
Standout feature
No standout feature to report
Age
Newer than 5% of single-family homes in Winter Haven
4,370 homes · Jul 2017 - Sep 2026
Compared against 40 similar homes sold within 1.15 mi.

About this property

Virtually Staged. Welcome home to this beautifully maintained midcentury gem, tucked in the highly sought-after Lake Elbert Trail neighborhood! Set on a sprawling quarter-acre-plus lot, this move-in ready beauty blends timeless character with modern comfort — featuring a stylish updated kitchen with brand-new appliances and fresh new carpet in every bedroom. Major peace-of-mind updates already done for you: roof (2023), water heater (2025), plumbing (2024), and electrical (2026). Step outside to a sprawling front yard and a fully fenced backyard — plus a bonus storage barn for all your extras. Homes like this in Lake Elbert Trail don't last — schedule your showing today!

Property details

Year built1951
Lot size0.28 ac
HOANot stated
Parking1-car
Days on market1
MLS#L4964980
Ceiling fansSolid surface countersSplit bedroomThermostatDishwasherElectric water heater
All features →
  • Ceiling fans
  • Solid surface counters
  • Split bedroom
  • Thermostat
  • Dishwasher
  • Electric water heater
  • Microwave
  • Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Carpet flooring
  • Ceramic tile flooring
  • Vinyl flooring
  • Central air conditioning
  • Central heating
  • Shingle roof
  • Slab foundation
  • Stucco construction
  • Single story
  • In garage
  • Electricity connected
  • Sewer connected
  • Water connected
  • Garage
  • Fireplace

The market for homes like this

Single-family homes with 3 bedrooms in Winter Haven
i
Median sold price$275,000380 sales · last 12 months
Median price per sq ft$177380 sales · last 12 months
Median rent$1,795/mo167 leases · last 12 months
Median days to lease35167 leases · last 12 months

Winter Haven, as its listings describe it

What agents stated on listings, 2006 – 2026i
Community pool70%of 938 listings
HOA fee, median$50/moof 1,080 listings
Has an association78%of 1,688 listings
Pets allowed84%of 2,317 listings
Minimum lease, most commonNo Minimum31% of 1,111 listings · next: 8–12 Months
Lease restrictions53%of 1,146 listings
Association approval required28%of 1,033 listings
Private pool5%of 2,488 listings
Gated17%of 938 listings
Public water · sewer99% · 98%of 1,383 · 1,450 listings
Flood zone (A or V)2%of 1,465 listings
55+ communityNo89% of 1,700 listings · next: Yes
Homestead share64%of 19,968 homes · county tax roll
Also stated: waterfront 6% of 1,701 listings; CDD 36% of 1,317.

Price and time on market

This listing against homes like iti
Price per sq ft
The seller has not permitted automated price comparisons
Time on market
The seller has not permitted automated comparisons
Price history
Listed at $258,500 since Sept. 7, 2026 with no price change

Cost of ownership

What this home costs to hold, from public recordsi
Current owner's taxes
i
$3,043 (2025)
As stated on the listing for 2025
Estimated taxes at this price
i
About $3,100/yr homesteaded, $3,900/yr as an investor
Estimated: the asking price through the county's price-to-value factor, at the parcel's published millage; assessments reset at sale
Typical electric bill
i
$166/mo (2024)
Typical: the utility's average residential bill for 2024 (not this home's)
Typical water and sewer
i
$80/mo at 5,000 gallons
Typical: the provider's published schedule at 5,000 gallons a month on a standard residential meter
THE NEIGHBORHOOD

Living in Winter Haven

City of Winter Haven · Polk County · ZIP 33881 · Flood zone X
Explore Winter Haven →
Homes19,968residential parcels
Median sold price$294,9001,137 sales · last 12 months
Vs. the prior year+0.6%1,137 sales this year · 1,143 sales the prior year
Median rent$1,800/mo479 leases · last 12 months
Homes that changed hands6%1,138 sales of 19,968 homes
Homestead share64%of 19,968 homes · county tax roll
Single-family homes in Winter Haven, by bedroomsFigures appear once a group has 40 sales
GROUPSALESMEDIAN SOLDMEDIAN RENT
All single-family homes · 12 months985$302,900$1,900/mo371 leases
2 bed53$220,000—
3 bed · this home380$275,000$1,795/mo167 leases
4 bed429$316,900$2,000/mo147 leases
5+ bed123$342,445$2,200/mo42 leases
All single-family homes · 24 months2,011$300,000$1,900/mo725 leases
Median price

Winter Haven homes sold for a median of $294,900 in the 12 months to Sept. 28, 2026.

1,137 sales
Price trend

That's 0.6% above the median for the 12 months before, $293,000.

1,137 sales this year · 1,143 sales the prior year
What's selling

Single-family detached homes made up 985 of the 1,137 sales in the same 12 months, at a median of $302,900.

985 of 1,137 sales
Not yet available here: rent and time-to-lease for townhomes.The Winter Haven record: homes, prices, rents, communities and listings →

Location

716 AVENUE I NE, WINTER HAVEN, FL 33881

Based on information from Stellar MLS® for the period January 29, 2006 through September 28, 2026.

Listings courtesy of Stellar MLS as distributed by MLS GRID

HomeProp is a licensed Florida real estate brokerage (License CQ1055163). Regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC), 400 W Robinson St, Orlando, FL 32801. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

← Browse homes for sale
Request a showing