Apollo Beach › Mirabay

5405 Tybee Island Dr

Apollo Beach, FL 33572
$1,875,000
4 bed4 bath4,095 sqftSingle-family home · built 2007

What stands out about this home

Compared with single-family homes like it, within product classi
Size
Larger than 88% of single-family homes sold in Mirabay
276 single-family home sales · Jan 2024 - Oct 2026
Price
The seller has not permitted automated price comparisons
Standout feature
A garage for 3 or more cars: 38% of single-family homes listed in Mirabay have one
153 single-family home listings · Feb 2023 - Oct 2026
Age
Newer than 35% of single-family homes in Mirabay
449 homes · Feb 2023 - Oct 2026
Compared against 40 similar homes sold within 0.49 mi.

About this property

Gracious waterfront living awaits on an oversized, over half-acre lot in the Bay Estates community of MiraBay. Custom John Cannon Mediterranean construction and numerous updates by the current owner deliver impressive attention to detail and thoughtful design elements throughout. Designer lighting, tray ceilings and refined finishes enhance the home’s elegant interiors. Positioned on a private cul-de-sac lot with approximately 200 feet of water frontage and tropical landscaping, the property is complemented by a private dock and 20,000-pound full-service boat lift on the lagoon. Designed primarily for single-level living, the home features generous gathering spaces, including a formal living room and light-filled great room with fully retractable sliders opening to the screened lanai. An adjoining breakfast area flows into the chef’s kitchen, appointed with quartz countertops, a center island, pot filler, and Bosch and KitchenAid appliances. The formal dining room provides an intimate setting for entertaining, complemented by an adjacent entertaining bar, wine refrigeration and a generous wine cellar. The primary suite features a welcoming sitting area, seamless access to the pool terrace, dual closets and a spacious bath with dual vanities, an oversized tub and signature walk-through shower overlooking the garden. The first floor also includes two guest bedrooms, one en suite, an additional full bath with direct pool access, a large laundry room and a private den or office. Upstairs, a bonus room opens to a tranquil waterfront terrace and is joined by a fourth bedroom and full bath. Designed for Florida waterfront living, the home opens to a generous lanai with covered dining, an outdoor kitchen and fireplace, along with a heated pool and spa, creating an inviting setting for relaxing, entertaining and enjoying spectacular sunsets. The current owner has made significant improvements, including a 2025 tile roof, newer HVAC systems, tankless water heater, pool heater, and updates to the dock electrical panel, motor and cables. Additional features include a three-car garage with EV charging, a water purification system and plantation shutters. Located within a private gated enclave inside MiraBay, residents enjoy an array of community amenities, including the Club & Spa, fitness facilities, spa services, resort-style pool with waterslide, splash pad, tennis, parks, playgrounds, water recreation, a community dock and storage options. Ideally located in Apollo Beach with convenient access to shopping and dining, the property also offers connectivity throughout the greater Tampa Bay area, including Tampa, St. Petersburg and Sarasota.

Property details

Year built2007
Lot size0.53 ac
HOA fee$190/yr
Parking3-car
Days on market4
MLS#TB8546404
BalconyOutdoor grillOutdoor kitchenRain guttersSidewalkCeiling fans
All features →
  • Balcony
  • Outdoor grill
  • Outdoor kitchen
  • Rain gutters
  • Sidewalk
  • Ceiling fans
  • Crown molding
  • Dry bar
  • Eat-in kitchen
  • High ceilings
  • Primary bedroom main floor
  • Split bedroom
  • Thermostat
  • Walk-in closets
  • Window treatments
  • Bar fridge
  • Built-in oven
  • Convection oven
  • Cooktop
  • Dishwasher
  • Disposal
  • Microwave
  • Range hood
  • Refrigerator
  • Water purifier
  • Carpet flooring
  • Tile flooring
  • Vinyl flooring
  • Wood flooring
  • Pool view
  • Water view
  • Central air conditioning
  • Zoned cooling
  • Central heating
  • Electric heating
  • Natural gas heating
  • Zoned heating
  • Tile roof
  • Slab foundation
  • Block construction
  • Stone construction
  • Stucco construction
  • Frame construction
  • Two stories
  • Inside laundry
  • Broadband internet available
  • Cable available
  • Electricity connected
  • Natural gas connected
  • Public utilities
  • Sewer connected
  • Gated community
  • Security system
  • Smoke detectors
  • Private pool
  • Garage
  • Fireplace
  • Waterfront
  • Quartz countertops

The market for homes like this

Single-family homes with 4 bedrooms in Mirabay
i
Median sold price$890,00067 sales · last 12 months
Median price per sq ft$28967 sales · last 12 months
Median rent$3,000/mo89 leases · last 12 months
Median days to lease3089 leases · last 12 months

Apollo Beach, as its listings describe it

What agents stated on listings, 2023 – 2026i
Community pool Mirabay99%of 170 listings
HOA fee, median Mirabay$16/moof 153 listings
Has an association Mirabay100%of 179 listings
Pets allowed Mirabay94%of 220 listings
Minimum lease, most common Mirabay1-2 Years46% of 149 listings · next: 8–12 Months
Lease restrictions Mirabay85%of 149 listings
Association approval required Mirabay23%of 149 listings
Private pool Mirabay40%of 222 listings
Gated Mirabay91%of 170 listings
Public water · sewer97% · 99%of 166 · 170 listings
Flood zone (A or V) Mirabay92%of 168 listings
55+ community MirabayNo100% of 180 listings
Homestead share Mirabay77%of 1,388 homes · county tax roll
Also stated: waterfront 51% of 180 listings in Mirabay; CDD 99% of 154 in Mirabay.

Price and time on market

This listing against homes like iti
Price per sq ft
The seller has not permitted automated price comparisons
Time on market
The seller has not permitted automated comparisons
Price history
Listed at $1,875,000 since Sept. 21, 2026 with no price change

Cost of ownership

What this home costs to hold, from public recordsi
Current owner's taxes
i
$46,375 for 2025 on the listing; about $35,306 on the 2026 roll
The listing and the county roll disagree materially; both are shown
Estimated taxes at this price
i
About $25,800/yr homesteaded, $26,600/yr as an investor
Estimated: the asking price through the county's price-to-value factor, at the parcel's published millage; assessments reset at sale
Typical electric bill
i
$166/mo (2024)
Typical: the utility's average residential bill for 2024 (not this home's)
Typical water and sewer
i
$98/mo at 5,000 gallons
Typical: the provider's published schedule at 5,000 gallons a month on a standard residential meter
THE NEIGHBORHOOD

Living in Apollo Beach

unincorporated Hillsborough County · Hillsborough County · ZIP 33572 · Apollo Beach (census-designated place) · Flood zone AE
Explore Apollo Beach →
Homes14,413residential parcels
Median sold price$469,999855 sales · last 12 months
Vs. the prior year+0.9%855 sales this year · 910 sales the prior year
Median rent$2,600/mo267 leases · last 12 months
Homes that changed hands6%855 sales of 14,413 homes
Homestead share73%of 14,413 homes · county tax roll
Single-family homes in Apollo Beach, by bedroomsFigures appear once a group has 40 sales
GROUPSALESMEDIAN SOLDMEDIAN RENT
All single-family homes · 12 months712$521,000$2,900/mo172 leases
2 bed17Not enough sales yet to report on their own
3 bed235$422,000$2,650/mo63 leases
4 bed · this home377$566,000$3,000/mo89 leases
5+ bed83$604,625—
All single-family homes · 24 months1,447$510,000$2,900/mo337 leases
Median price

Apollo Beach homes sold for a median of $469,999 in the 12 months to Oct. 11, 2026.

855 sales
Price trend

That's 0.9% above the median for the 12 months before, $465,719.

855 sales this year · 910 sales the prior year
What's selling

Single-family detached homes made up 712 of the 855 sales in the same 12 months, at a median of $521,000.

712 of 855 sales
Not yet available here: rent and time-to-lease for villas.The Apollo Beach record: homes, prices, rents, communities and listings →

Location

5405 TYBEE ISLAND DR, APOLLO BEACH, FL 33572

Nearby homes for sale in Apollo Beach

Based on information from Stellar MLS® for the period February 17, 2023 through October 11, 2026.

Listings courtesy of Stellar MLS as distributed by MLS GRID

HomeProp is a licensed Florida real estate brokerage (License CQ1055163). Regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC), 400 W Robinson St, Orlando, FL 32801. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

← Browse homes for sale
Request a showing