Fish Hawk › Fishhawk Ranch

5911 Phoebenest Dr

Lithia, FL 33547
$415,000
3 bed2 bath1,720 sqftVilla · built 2005

What stands out about this home

Compared with villas like it, within product classi
Size
Larger than 52% of villas sold in Fishhawk Ranch
65 villa sales · Jan 2024 - Oct 2026
Price
The seller has not permitted automated price comparisons
Standout feature
No standout feature to report
Age
Newer than 56% of villas in Fishhawk Ranch
100 homes · Oct 2023 - Oct 2026
Compared against 40 similar homes sold within 2.53 mi.

About this property

Perfectly positioned waterfront living in the tucked away village of Phoebe Park in FishHawk Ranch, this villa provides residents a lifestyle with a gated entrance, dedicated pool, clubhouse, sidewalks, and maintenance-free living. The thoughtful floor plan includes a split bedroom layout, open-concept family room with dining space, dedicated sitting area, and extended screened lanai. The spacious kitchen offers a moveable island ideal for casual dining or gatherings. The upgraded stainless steel appliances include a natural gas, convection stove where you have precise, immediate heat control allowing your inner Julia Child to come out. You will find the kitchen is the heart of the home with upgrades include stone counters, decorative backsplash, pullout shelving in lower cabinets, and motion sensor under-cabinet lighting. Pride of home ownership is evident, showcasing meticulous care and high-end upgrades. The private screened lanai creates the perfect setting for year-round enjoyment which offers ceramic tile flooring, a covered sitting area, and perfectly appointed views of pond and conservation area for watching nature to your hearts content. The primary suite supports relaxation with a newly remodeled walk-in shower featuring leathered granite countertops, dual sinks, his and hers closets with custom storage system, and a private water closet. Your retreat provides private sliding door access to the lanai so you can enjoy morning meditation without disrupting other family members. This ground level villa continues with two additional guest rooms, a full bathroom with shower/ tub combo, laundry room, and 2-car garage. Added plus are the gas appliances (stove, dryer, water heater, and heating). Located within proximity to the private pool, clubhouse, and FishHawk Creek Elementary, this maintenance-free community is situated in the award-winning FishHawk Ranch, renowned for its 28 miles of nature pathways and A-rated schools: FishHawk Creek Elementary, Randall Middle, and Newsome High. Revel in the multitude of FishHawk's amenities to include a state-of-the-art sports complex, several clubhouses, pickleball courts, tennis club, skate and dog parks, four resort-style pools, and centrally positioned community Park Square. FishHawk Ranch is 20+ miles inland, far enough away to weather Florida's storms, which also includes underground utilities. FishHawk Ranch is a reasonable 45-minute drive to Tampa International Airport and award winning beaches.

Property details

Year built2005
Lot size0.12 ac
HOA + Association 2 fees$315/mo HOA + $125/yr second association
Parking2-car
Days on market29
MLS#TB8545207
Private entrancePrivate mailboxBuilt-in featuresCeiling fansEat-in kitchenLiving/dining combo
All features →
  • Private entrance
  • Private mailbox
  • Built-in features
  • Ceiling fans
  • Eat-in kitchen
  • Living/dining combo
  • Primary bedroom main floor
  • Smart home
  • Solid surface counters
  • Split bedroom
  • Thermostat
  • Tray ceilings
  • Walk-in closets
  • Window treatments
  • Convection oven
  • Dishwasher
  • Disposal
  • Dryer
  • Gas water heater
  • Microwave
  • Refrigerator
  • Washer
  • Water view
  • Central air conditioning
  • Natural gas heating
  • Shingle roof
  • Slab foundation
  • Stucco construction
  • Single story
  • Gas dryer hookup
  • Laundry room
  • Cable connected
  • Electricity connected
  • Natural gas connected
  • Sewer connected
  • Underground utilities
  • Water connected
  • Gated community
  • Smoke detectors
  • Garage
  • Waterfront
  • Granite countertops
  • Stainless steel appliances

The market for homes like this

Villas in Fishhawk Ranch · all sizes
Too few 3-bedroom villa sales here to report on their own, so these cover every villa in Fish Hawk.i
Median sold price$355,00050 sales · last 24 months
Median price per sq ft$21350 sales · last 24 months

Fish Hawk, as its listings describe it

What agents stated on listings, 2007 – 2026i
Community pool Fishhawk Ranch94%of 318 listings
HOA fee, median Fishhawk Ranch$36/moof 262 listings
Has an association Fishhawk Ranch99%of 362 listings
Pets allowed Fishhawk Ranch95%of 630 listings
Minimum lease, most common Fishhawk Ranch7 Months39% of 250 listings · next: 1–2 Years
Lease restrictions Fishhawk Ranch78%of 250 listings
Association approval required Fishhawk Ranch52%of 251 listings
Private pool Fishhawk Ranch16%of 638 listings
Gated Fishhawk Ranch30%of 318 listings
Public water · sewer99% · 99%of 323 · 335 listings
Flood zone (A or V) Fishhawk Ranch1%of 309 listings
55+ community Fishhawk RanchNo95% of 363 listings · next: Yes
Homestead share Fishhawk Ranch78%of 5,267 homes · county tax roll
Also stated: waterfront 5% of 364 listings in Fishhawk Ranch; CDD 96% of 266 in Fishhawk Ranch.

Price and time on market

This listing against homes like iti
Price per sq ft
The seller has not permitted automated price comparisons
Time on market
The seller has not permitted automated comparisons
Price history
Listed at $415,000 since Sept. 2, 2026 with no price change

Cost of ownership

What this home costs to hold, from public recordsi
Current owner's taxes
i
$6,673 for 2025 on the listing; about $4,281 on the 2026 roll
The listing and the county roll disagree materially; both are shown
Estimated taxes at this price
i
About $5,100/yr homesteaded, $5,900/yr as an investor
Estimated: the asking price through the county's price-to-value factor, at the parcel's published millage; assessments reset at sale
Typical electric bill
i
$166/mo (2024)
Typical: the utility's average residential bill for 2024 (not this home's)
Typical water and sewer
i
$98/mo at 5,000 gallons
Typical: the provider's published schedule at 5,000 gallons a month on a standard residential meter
THE NEIGHBORHOOD

Living in Fish Hawk

unincorporated Hillsborough County · Hillsborough County · ZIP 33547 · Fish Hawk (census-designated place) · Flood zone X
Explore Fish Hawk →
Homes7,693residential parcels
Median sold price$550,000387 sales · last 12 months
Vs. the prior year-1.6%387 sales this year · 362 sales the prior year
Median rent$2,600/mo276 leases · last 12 months
Homes that changed hands5%387 sales of 7,693 homes
Homestead share77%of 7,693 homes · county tax roll
Villas in Fish Hawk, by bedroomsFigures appear once a group has 40 sales
GROUPSALESMEDIAN SOLDMEDIAN RENT
All villas · 12 months24Not enough sales yet to report on their own
2 bed10Not enough sales yet to report on their own
3 bed · this home14Not enough sales yet to report on their own
All villas · 24 months50$355,000—
Median price

Fish Hawk homes sold for a median of $550,000 in the 12 months to Oct. 11, 2026.

387 sales
Price trend

That's 1.6% below the median for the 12 months before, $559,000.

387 sales this year · 362 sales the prior year
What's selling

Single-family detached homes made up 315 of the 387 sales in the same 12 months, at a median of $605,000.

315 of 387 sales

Location

5911 PHOEBENEST DR, LITHIA, FL 33547

Nearby homes for sale in Lithia

Based on information from Stellar MLS® for the period May 4, 2007 through October 11, 2026.

Listings courtesy of Stellar MLS as distributed by MLS GRID

HomeProp is a licensed Florida real estate brokerage (License CQ1055163). Regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC), 400 W Robinson St, Orlando, FL 32801. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

← Browse homes for sale
Request a showing