Thonotosassa › Jefferson Heights

12231 Kelly Ln

Thonotosassa, FL 33592
$519,000
5 bed2 bath2,586 sqftSingle-family home · built 1972

Listed at $205 per sq ft. Median for single-family homes in Thonotosassa sold in the last 12 months: $221 per sq ft.

130 sales · Stellar MLS, credited below

What stands out about this home

Compared with single-family homes like it, within product classi
Size
Larger than 57% of single-family homes sold in Thonotosassa
315 single-family home sales · Jan 2024 - Oct 2026
Price
Listed 11% below the typical price for a single-family home its size in Thonotosassa
315 single-family home sales · Jan 2024 - Oct 2026
Standout feature
A private pool: 28% of single-family homes listed in Thonotosassa have one
186 single-family home listings · Feb 2019 - Oct 2026
Age
Newer than 11% of single-family homes in Thonotosassa
518 homes · Feb 2019 - Oct 2026
Compared against 40 similar homes sold within 4.67 mi.

About this property

Motivated Seller is offering a $10,000 concession to use for rate buy-down or closing costs! Ask your Realtor for details. Looking for tranquility but close to all the conveniences? Pool, Workshop, & Conservation Views! Welcome home to 12231 Kelly Lane, a spacious 4-bedroom (plus office or use as 5th bedroom), 2-bathroom residence offering 2,586 sq ft of living space, and a private backyard paradise. Be sure to watch the video walkthrough! Set on a massive 0.43-acre lot under mature oak trees, this immaculate move-in-ready property delivers the perfect blend of indoor comfort, outdoor recreation, and peaceful seclusion with NO HOA or CDDs. The interior features 4 bedrooms, an extra office/flex room/bedroom, and bamboo wood floors and tile throughout. The central kitchen is designed with a convenient pass-through opening directly to the massive main family room, which features a wood-burning fireplace, perfect for family time or entertaining guests. Flexible storage, including two dedicated rooms off the laundry area, ideal for pantry overflow or additional climate-controlled storage needs. All windows have been updated for energy-efficiency. Enjoy sunny Florida days on your fully screened, covered patio overlooking an in-ground swimming pool with conservation backdrop. The rear lot line borders natural conservation land, ensuring perpetual privacy with no rear neighbors, and a 5-minute trail walk taking you directly to the Hillsborough River. Abundant wildlife to enjoy, including tortoises, falcons, owls, sandhill cranes, deer, and more. The detached garage/workshop provides exceptional space for vehicles, a home workshop, or extra gear. Schedule your private showing today! Very few homes come available in this neighborhood!

Property details

Year built1972
Lot size0.43 ac
HOANot stated
Parking2-car
Days on market58
MLS#TB8540679
StorageCrown moldingDishwasherMicrowaveRangeRefrigerator
All features →
  • Storage
  • Crown molding
  • Dishwasher
  • Microwave
  • Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Ceramic tile flooring
  • Wood flooring
  • Pool view
  • Trees or woods view
  • Central air conditioning
  • Central heating
  • Shingle roof
  • Slab foundation
  • Block construction
  • Stucco construction
  • Single story
  • Inside laundry
  • Broadband internet available
  • Cable available
  • Electricity connected
  • Smoke detectors
  • Private pool
  • Garage

The market for homes like this

Single-family homes in Thonotosassa · all sizes
Too few 5+-bedroom single-family home sales here to report on their own, so these cover every single-family home in Thonotosassa.i
Median sold price$482,405130 sales · last 12 months
Median price per sq ft$221130 sales · last 12 months

Thonotosassa, as its listings describe it

What agents stated on listings, 2019 – 2026i
Community pool12%of 104 listings
HOA fee, median$92/moof 105 listings
Has an association57%of 222 listings
Pets allowed90%of 206 listings
Minimum lease, most commonNo Minimum50% of 183 listings · next: 6 Months
Lease restrictions39%of 184 listings
Association approval required37%of 126 listings
Private pool22%of 264 listings
Gated25%of 104 listings
Public water · sewer48% · 48%of 206 · 209 listings
Flood zone (A or V)6%of 210 listings
55+ communityNo100% of 224 listings
Homestead share71%of 4,352 homes · county tax roll
Also stated: waterfront 8% of 224 listings; CDD 5% of 194.

Price and time on market

This listing against homes like iti
Price per sq ft
Listed at $205 per sq ft, 7% below the $221 median for single-family homes in Thonotosassa sold in the last 12 months
130 sales · last 12 months
Time on market
On the market 3 days; single-family homes in Thonotosassa took a median of 36 days to sell in the last 12 months
130 sales · last 12 months
Price history
Listed at $529,000 since Aug. 20, 2026 with no price change

Cost of ownership

What this home costs to hold, from public recordsi
Current owner's taxes
i
$2,768 (2025)
As stated on the listing for 2025
Estimated taxes at this price
i
About $6,700/yr homesteaded, $7,500/yr as an investor
Estimated: the asking price through the county's price-to-value factor, at the parcel's published millage; assessments reset at sale
Typical electric bill
i
$166/mo (2024)
Typical: the utility's average residential bill for 2024 (not this home's)
Typical water and sewer
i
$98/mo at 5,000 gallons
Typical: the provider's published schedule at 5,000 gallons a month on a standard residential meter
THE NEIGHBORHOOD

Living in Thonotosassa

unincorporated Hillsborough County · Hillsborough County · ZIP 33592 · Thonotosassa (census-designated place) · Flood zone X
Explore Thonotosassa →
Homes4,352residential parcels
Median sold price$458,720154 sales · last 12 months
Vs. the prior year+1.9%154 sales this year · 122 sales the prior year
Median rentNot enough sales yet to report on their own
Homes that changed hands4%154 sales of 4,352 homes
Homestead share71%of 4,352 homes · county tax roll
Single-family homes in Thonotosassa, by bedroomsFigures appear once a group has 40 sales
GROUPSALESMEDIAN SOLDMEDIAN RENT
All single-family homes · 12 months130$482,405—
2 bed4Not enough sales yet to report on their own
3 bed40$421,480—
4 bed63$526,200—
5+ bed · this home23Not enough sales yet to report on their own
All single-family homes · 24 months233$493,460—
Median price

Thonotosassa homes sold for a median of $458,720 in the 12 months to Oct. 11, 2026.

154 sales
Price trend

That's 1.9% above the median for the 12 months before, $450,000.

154 sales this year · 122 sales the prior year
What's selling

Single-family detached homes made up 130 of the 154 sales in the same 12 months, at a median of $482,405.

130 of 154 sales
Not yet available here: rent and time-to-lease for single-family homes.The Thonotosassa record: homes, prices, rents, communities and listings →

Location

12231 KELLY LN, THONOTOSASSA, FL 33592

Nearby homes for sale in Thonotosassa

Based on information from Stellar MLS® for the period February 19, 2019 through October 11, 2026.

Listings courtesy of Stellar MLS as distributed by MLS GRID

HomeProp is a licensed Florida real estate brokerage (License CQ1055163). Regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC), 400 W Robinson St, Orlando, FL 32801. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

← Browse homes for sale
Request a showing